Sunday NY Times – Neither Here Nor There

Press coverage of the European debt crisis and its potential impact on the US is a favorite topic of the media these days.  A case in point is “Suddenly, Over There Is Over Here,” a column in The New York Times Sunday Business section on September 18.

According to the column, there are two major risks facing US investors from the problems in Europe.  Only one concerns us here:  “…the potential for losses incurred by financial institutions that wrote credit insurance on European government debt and the European banks that own so much of that paper.”

How much could these losses total?  According to DTCC, and as the article notes, the net CDS exposure on Greece, Spain, Portugal and Ireland is $23.6 billion.  Does that mean that nearly $24 billion could change hands if ALL of these countries defaulted?  Well, no.  That’s because exposures are marked-to-market and roughly 90% of that market value is secured by collateral.  In addition, the amount the protection sellers pays to the protection buyers is further reduced by the recovery value of the bonds upon which protection was sold.  For sovereigns, that could be in the range of 40% to 50%.

So if we do the math, the actual cash payout on all the CDS on Greece, Spain, Portugal and Ireland would be less than $1 billion:

Net CDS notional on four sovereigns:               $23.6 billion

Less 90% collateralization of mark to market exposure
(
assuming MTM is 40% of par)                        13.6 billion
Less recovery value of bonds referenced by CDS
 (assuming recovery value is 40% of par)             9.4 billion
                                                   ————-
Total cash payout                                  $ 0.6 billion

   
This doesn’t mean, by the way, that the losses by CDS sellers would be less than $1 billion.  The actual losses incurred would be the amount of protection sold less the premiums received and the recovery value of the bonds on which protection was sold.   But it does mean that the actual cash paid out by institutions in the event of a loss is likely to be a very manageable number.

You can also apply this calculation to estimate what the payouts would be on financial institutions that deal in CDS.  The net notional outstanding on the world’s 10 largest financial institutions is about $37.5 billion. 

Now contrast the figures on sovereign CDS with the size of the government bond markets for the four sovereigns:

   Greece:     $   484 billion
   Spain:          896 billion  
   Portugal:       219 billion
   Ireland:        154 billion
—————-

   Total:      $ 1.753 trillion
(Data: Bloomberg, September 20, 2011)

Obviously, the CDS market is a tiny fraction of the size of the underlying sovereign debt market.

One additional point about the story requires clarification.  The article states that CDS “instruments trade in secret.”  The fact is:  a CDS trade repository that captures virtually all CDS trade activity is up and running (and has been for several years).  Some of this information is public (you can access it here).  More granular information is available to regulators.  As a result, transparency in the CDS market – as well as with other segments of the OTC derivatives markets – is significantly improved over the past few years.  In fact, Dodd-Frank and other regulations do not require providing additional public information on counterparty positions and exposures. 

Finally, the article states that “the huge market in credit default swaps remains unregulated and remains in the shadows.”  In light of the facts regarding trade repositories and with the passage of Dodd-Frank, we can only say:  “Really?”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s